The stock market’s Halloween season paints an intriguing picture this year. The S&P 500 has climbed about 35% from April lows, yet market fears keep growing. The market’s “fear gauge” (VIX) jumped over 25% on October 10 – marking its biggest single-day move in six months.
Most investors know about the stock market Halloween effect. October has earned quite a reputation for scary market swings. The infamous “Black Monday” crash on October 19, 1987, saw the S&P 500 drop by 20.5%. But seasoned investors see these seasonal fears as chances to profit rather than signals to run.
Market worries go beyond just Halloween superstitions these days. The S&P 500 trades at a P/E of 28, which sits uncomfortably close to the 1990s dotcom peak of around 30. A record 54% of global fund managers think AI stocks have entered bubble territory. On top of that, NYSE margin debt has shot up more than 32% since April’s end. These numbers raise real questions about market stability.
Expat Wealth At Work will demonstrate why October’s eerie reputation may not warrant all the excitement and equip you with the skills to navigate this period with rationality rather than fear.
Why October Feels Risky for Investors
Investors not only fear October superstitiously, but it also bears a psychological burden unlike any other month. Historical patterns and media coverage have shaped this reputation over time.
The legacy of October crashes
The stock market’s history is full of October disasters that have left lasting marks on investor psychology. Black Monday hit hard on October 28, 1929, when the Dow fell by nearly 13%. The next day brought another 12% drop. This crash led to the Great Depression, and by summer 1932, the market had lost 89% of its value. The S&P dropped more than 20% in a single day during Black Monday 1987. The market took another big hit in October 2008 during the global financial crisis – the S&P 500 fell by nearly 17% that month.
The rise of the ‘stock market Halloween effect’
The stock market Halloween effect has shown up consistently in markets everywhere. This investing theory suggests that stocks do better between October 31 and May 1 than during other times of the year. It’s a timing strategy that ties into the old saying, “Sell in May and go away.” The numbers back the idea up – stocks rose 65% of the time from October’s end to May’s beginning between 1920 and 1970, compared to just 58% from May to October. A newer study published by researchers found this effect in 36 out of 37 markets worldwide.
How media amplifies seasonal fear
Media coverage shapes investor sentiment, especially during volatile periods. Trading decisions change based on what the media reports, but not in a balanced way. Investors brush off bad news when markets rise but fixate on it during downturns. Bad news hits harder because investors are extra sensitive to negative coverage. Market declines make pessimistic news articles powerful enough to sway decisions. This creates a cycle where October’s bad reputation triggers more worry, which leads to panic-driven selling even when nothing’s wrong with market fundamentals.
What Smart Investors See Instead
Smart market players look past October fears while others panic. They have a better perspective about what people call the “stock market Halloween” period.
Long-term trends vs. short-term noise
Smart investors know that history backs patient investing. The S&P 500’s track record since the 1920s shows investors rarely lost money over 20-year periods. This holds true even through the Great Depression and financial crisis. Yes, it is worth noting that the S&P 500 had yearly losses in just 13 years, between 1974 and 2024. Markets tend to go up more than down. This big-picture view helps investors avoid emotional choices that hurt their returns.
Why volatility can be an opportunity
The market turbulence gives smart investors a chance to profit. To cite an instance, see how price swings create chances for quick gains. Prices move faster during these times, and upward breakouts can lead to big profits right away. On top of that, it lets investors buy excellent stocks at lower prices. Austin Pickle, a representative from Wells Fargo Investment Institute, articulates this point effectively: “Volatility—and opportunity—have arrived.” Investors who stay in the market can rebalance their portfolios and buy assets at better prices.
The role of earnings season in October
October’s earnings reports often balance out seasonal fears with solid company results. Currently, 29% of S&P 500 companies have shared their Q3 2025 numbers. Analysts expect 9.2% earnings-per-share growth. This would be the ninth straight quarter of earnings growth. The news gets better as 87% of reporting S&P 500 companies beat earnings estimates. Revenue numbers look good too, with 83% doing better than expected. These strong results give smart investors real reasons to stay invested despite “stock market Halloween effect” fears.
Key Market Fears—and Why They’re Overblown
The “stock market Halloween” period brings more than just seasonal fears. A closer look at the data shows these economic worries might not be as scary as they seem.
1. AI bubble comparisons to dot-com era
The AI market today looks quite different from the 1990s tech bubble. About 54% of fund managers think AI stocks are in a bubble. But modern tech companies show much stronger fundamentals. Unlike dot-com companies that crashed with 9.6x price-to-sales ratios, today’s tech giants run profitable businesses and hold large cash reserves.
2. Margin debt and leverage concerns
NYSE margin debt has jumped 32% since April, making debt warnings seem reasonable. The real story emerges from a broader view. Current margin levels as a percentage of total market value sit at 2.1%. This number stays nowhere near the 3.5% mark that warned of past market corrections.
3. Fed rate cuts and inflation worries
Many worry that the Fed’s rate-cutting means the economy is weak. However, historical evidence suggests otherwise. Markets typically gain 15% in the year after the first rate cut. Better yet, inflation has dropped from its 9.1% peak to 2.4%. This shows the Fed’s strategy works without pushing us into recession.
4. Trade tensions and tariff threats
Trade war concerns pop up often during the “stock market Halloween effect” season. Past tariffs barely left a mark on broad market indexes. The S&P 500 kept growing through the 2018-2019 tariff battles. Markets tend to overreact to trade news at first but learn to deal with new trade rules quickly.
How Smart Investors Prepare
Smart investors develop a toolkit of strategies before the “stock market Halloween” season arrives to prepare for October’s market volatility.
Broadening investment across asset classes
Smart investors know that proper diversification goes beyond just holding different stocks. They spread investments across uncorrelated assets, which react differently to economic events. Multiple layers of protection emerge during market turbulence when you mix stocks, bonds, real estate, and commodities. This strategy reduces exposure to any single underperforming asset class. The selection of assets with low correlation ensures that gains in one area can offset losses elsewhere.
Using volatility to rebalance portfolios
Disciplined investors find unique rebalancing opportunities during October volatility. The “buy low, sell high” principle works through rebalancing, as investors sell outperformers and buy underperformers. This process prevents portfolios from becoming overweight in one asset class while you retain your desired risk level. Investors can purchase assets at attractive valuations during market downturns, though many find this psychologically challenging.
Avoiding emotional decision-making
Emotional investing often guides investors to buy high during booms and sell low during downturns. The numbers tell the story—average investors earned 6.5% over 30 years, compared to 8.7% from a disciplined 65/35 stock/bond portfolio, with emotional behaviour causing the difference.
Sign up to receive the latest news and insights from our experts!
Poor timing decisions fade away when you create a pre-approved strategy that eliminates uncertainty and behavioural biases. Your discipline strengthens when you write down specific actions for different market thresholds, like, “If markets drop 10%, I’ll rebalance but not sell.”
Focusing on fundamentals, not fear
Understanding what you own comes from fundamentals-driven analysis. Business performance indicators like revenue, cash flows, and margins keep you grounded instead of market headlines. This method changes your investment approach and helps build a portfolio of businesses you understand rather than price tickers. The focus on real business value keeps you centred when headlines spark fear or excitement during the “stock market Halloween effect” season.
Conclusion
Smart investors know that October’s reputation for market turbulence shouldn’t let fear drive their investment decisions. Market history proves that disciplined approaches beat reactive, emotional strategies. Your best strategy during the stock market Halloween season stems from solid principles rather than seasonal fears.
Markets generally trend upward over time, despite October’s scary reputation. Concerns regarding AI bubbles, margin debt levels, Fed policy, and trade tensions appear exaggerated when compared to past trends. Market swings create chances for level-headed investors to succeed.
Smart investors follow proven tactics instead of dreading October. They ensure proper diversification across unrelated asset classes. Market volatility becomes their chance to rebalance portfolios strategically. Written plans help them avoid emotional choices during market swings. Business fundamentals matter more than scary headlines.
The stock market Halloween effect resembles a haunted house – it scares people who don’t understand how it works. Historical knowledge and sound investment strategies can turn this scary season into a chance for long-term portfolio growth. Success in investing depends on maintaining discipline whatever the month, not on timing seasonal patterns.
English 
Dutch
[…] Tech stock bubble warnings flash red across Wall Street as valuations reach dot-com crash levels. Your technology investments have likely shot up fast, and you might wonder if this meteoric rise will last—or if you should prepare for a devastating correction. […]